Stop Kiss Spoiler-free review

Stop Kiss - 7.5 out of 10 stars
Theatre Guild Student Society
Tickets here: STOP KISS TICKETS

Playing at the Little Theatre for two more nights, Stop Kiss, directed by Josh Manoa, confronts a theme that, regrettably, remains all too relevant in 2025: homophobia.

Written in 1998 by American playwright Diana Son, Stop Kiss remains a poignant reflection on the fragility of intimacy in an intolerant world. The play’s non-linear structure intercuts between "before" and "after" a violent attack against two women. The continuous scene changes sometimes fragment momentum. The pacing stretches beyond the advertised 100 minutes, closer to two hours, and the absence of an interval leaves little space for the audience to process the emotional weight of the unfolding story. An intermission might have allowed a moment’s breath, particularly in a production so emotionally charged.

The play follows Callie, a New York traffic reporter adrift in comfortable mediocrity. Esther Burnett captures Callie’s hesitancy and internal conflict with quiet finesse. Her early moments on stage feel tentative, yet as the story deepens, Burnett’s performance blossoms into something rich and resonant — especially in Callie’s gut-wrenching recollection of the assault. Burnett’s Callie embodies the painful contradiction of love and fear, reminding us that personal growth often emerges through tragedy.

Elizabeth “Ellie” Lijo’s Sara, by contrast, brims with openness and sincerity. Newly arrived from St. Louis to teach in a Bronx public school, Sara represents hope — restless, idealistic, and unguarded. Lijo commands the audience’s attention not through grand gestures but through an authenticity that feels almost effortless. Her Sara radiates an optimism that cuts through the darkness of the play. Though the sound mix obscured her early lines, Lijo soon found even footing, delivering moments of genuine joy and heartbreak in equal measure. Her scenes opposite Burnett carry gentle tension; each glance and hesitation feels truthful, delicately capturing the wonder of discovering new affection.

Together, Burnett and Lijo craft an expressive and believable rapport. Their chemistry is convincing yet refreshingly understated, reflecting the awkward charm of early romance. Their scenes together pulse with genuine warmth, making the violence that later intrudes jarring. Every brush of contact carries meaning. Despite the absence of an intimacy coordinator credit, their moments of physical closeness feel thoughtful and safe — the product of robust collaboration and careful direction.

Supporting this central duo, Jalen Berry’s George — Callie’s complicated, on–again, off–again boyfriend — provides grounded contrast. Berry plays George with restraint, acknowledging his privilege and confusion without tipping into caricature. It’s a commendable performance from a freshman actor who clearly understands the text’s emotional layers.

Liam Warmeant’s Peter, Sara’s ex-boyfriend, delivers controlled intensity. His portrayal edges toward menace; Peter isn’t a villain in the traditional sense, but an emblem of the suffocating past Sara desires to outgrow. Warmeant’s clipped tone and insistent presence make him an effective foil, setting the stage for the independence Sara seeks to claim.

As Detective Cole, Ashraf Abdul Halim captures the abrasive cynicism of a police officer too jaded to recognise a hate crime for what it is, a portrayal reminiscent of the detective noir archetype.

Zoe Russell-von Bujdoss takes on dual roles as Nurse and Mrs. Winsley. Being able to switch between the warmth and quiet compassion of the Nurse, and Mrs. Winsley’s nosy concern and wary detachment showcases great dramatic timing. The Nurse’s adds the needed reprieve from tension, while Mrs. Winsley’s adds dimension to the play’s depiction of New York’s messy, intersecting communities. Russell-von Bujdoss’s attention to physicality differentiates her characters cleanly, reinforcing how even small roles contribute meaningfully to the story’s fabric.

In their directorial debut, Josh Manoa demonstrates a blend of sensitivity and ambition. Their decision to lean into the non-chronological structure, reveals confidence in the text’s emotional rhythm. The result demands active engagement from the audience, urging them to piece together cause and consequence, love and injury, in tandem with the characters.

The production’s design work complements this tonal precision beautifully. Jarrod Matulick’s sound design and original composition forms the emotional backbone. A busy, layered soundscape evokes the constant hum of New York— distant sounds, passing traffic, the muffled buzz of late-night pedestrians. These auditory textures anchor each scene in place and time. Matulick’s live keyboard underscoring during scene transitions keeps the audience tuned in while the backstage crew move about as swiftly as possible. The moment within the opening scene regarding the jazz motif was sly and self-aware, drawing a thread of dark humour through the performance, only amplified by the mention and introduction of the saxophone in the track.

The highlight arrives in the form of an original song, written and sung by Katie Wicker with performances by Macey Lawson and Zoe Russell-von Bujdoss. Its tone and lyrics encapsulate the play. The audience’s hushed response spoke to its effectiveness.

Visually, the production remains faithful to late-90s New York authenticity. Set designer James Davey constructs a lived-in apartment space. The red TV topped with a coat-hanger antenna, the scatter of books, and the worn fold-out sofa — each detail anchors us in a world that feels tactile and specific. Props by Jack Clark and Parris Crouch amplify this sense of realism, providing dynamic transitions that mirror the characters’ emotional shifts.

Costume designer Isobel Watson, assisted by Mona Mortazavi, excels in articulating shifts in time and tone through wardrobe choices. Subtle changes help guide the audience through the production’s nonlinear timeline without need for explicit markers.

At a time when conversations about safety, prejudice, and identity still dominate discourse, Stop Kiss feels tragically current. Manoa’s production honours this with honesty and compassion. The tenderness between Callie and Sara, the resilience they inspire in each other, and the lingering ache of what follows resonate deeply with contemporary audiences. Ultimately, Little Theatre’s Stop Kiss is a production that champions authenticity over spectacle. It’s a powerful reminder that stories of queer love are still necessary and remain urgent.

- Andrew Broadbent

Comments