A New Musical: A New Musical Spoiler Free Review (kinda)

A New Musical: A New Musical - 9 out of 10
T&R Productions
TICKETS: End of Season

Twelve months ago, Thomas White and Riley Mobbs set out to write a musical for their Year 11 Research Project. Fast forward a year, and their original work has just completed its pilot run to four supportive audiences, even earning standing ovations on closing night. True to their mysterious marketing, T&R Productions revealed just enough to intrigue without giving too much away. When the show opens with the most delightfully questionable rendition of Photograph you’ll ever see, it’s clear the audience is in for a fun, unpredictable night.

A New Musical: A New Musical is comedic genius in more ways than one. With book, music, and lyrics jointly credited to White and Mobbs, it’s fair to say the pair deserve equal praise across the board. Together they’ve assembled a dedicated cast of now–Year 12 students (plus one alum), who bring the story to life with energy and affection for the material.

We meet Sebastian, a theatre reviewer fed up with critiquing lacklustre jukebox musicals. After quitting his job, he laments the lack of originality on stage and decides to write his own musical. To preserve the magic of future performances, I won’t spoil any more, except to say this show deserves another run and even licensing opportunities once any adjustments are made.

Playing Sebastian, co-writer Thomas White delivers a committed and believable performance. His understanding of the role is evident through his expressive mannerisms and well-timed comedic beats. At times, microphone placement slightly hindered the clarity of his vocals, particularly during his faster musical number, but his characterisation held strong throughout.

Amelie Cowley shines as Grace, Sebastian’s long-suffering wife who shoulders the financial burden as her husband chases creative fulfilment. Cowley’s portrayal is grounded, heartfelt, and impressively mature. Her vocals soar in “Stone” and “My Own Song,” two of the musical’s many standout moments.

Co-creator Riley Mobbs takes on Hans, Sebastian’s former boss and the red-herring antagonist. Mobbs is a natural showman, stealing scenes with his larger-than-life energy. His comedic timing peaks during a tap number with tear-away pants, and a tongue-in-cheek fourth-wall break that hilariously references the co-creator’s own writing resulting in quick costume challenges.

Charlotte Butler gives a strong turn as the secretary and conveniently, Sebastian’s next-door neighbour. Her character’s proximity allows for plenty of gossip and plot-driving observations, and Butler makes the most of every moment she’s given on stage.

Sam White delights as Blake, a charmingly desperate actor determined to land a role in Sebastian’s new musical. White’s charisma and comic instincts make him instantly likeable, culminating in a memorable “Broadway debut” and an audacious kiss that earns thunderous applause. As a first-year acting student at Flinders University, he’s clearly one to watch.

Playing Toni, Chelsey Binns impresses with her powerful vocals and articulate delivery. Though her character doesn’t share Blake’s Broadway fate, Binns’ poise and confidence on stage mark her as a future standout in musical theatre.

Kyle Mobbs brings flair to Austin, the financier with hidden motives. His physicality and fearless character work shine, particularly when Austin unexpectedly steps into a missing cast member’s role – a clever and hilarious moment that exemplifies this show’s meta-humour.

Rounding out the ensemble, Alex Carpenter is great as Nikolas Valentine and several smaller characters, including the coffee shop patron and Grace’s boss. His performance, from the opening number to the final reveal, connects the story’s many meta threads. Carpenter’s blend of comedy and mystery leaves a lasting impression.

Very deliberately, I’ve avoided mentioning the choreography until now — because it truly deserves its own spotlight. Kyle Mobbs, credited as choreographer, has done a wonderful job crafting inventive, varied routines that perfectly complement each musical moment. His understanding that not every song needs an elaborate dance sequence is commendable, and he balances this restraint by infusing the many scene changes with lively, dance-driven transitions. These moments are so dynamic and polished that they become as entertaining as the musical numbers themselves.

In addition to co-creating this musical, Riley Mobbs takes the helm as Director while Thomas White serves as Musical Director, ensuring their shared vision carries seamlessly from page to stage. The meta written into this musical was appreciated by the audience, and breaking the fourth wall to ensure this reviewer is involved no less than three times was a fun addition, while reviewing a musical about a reviewer no less.

As with any new production, a few technical hiccups surfaced, particularly with microphones and lighting. However, the technical team deserves praise for their calm professionalism and quick responses, addressing issues in real time and keeping the show moving without losing pace or energy.

In short, A New Musical: A New Musical is witty, self-aware, and full of heart. Thomas White and Riley Mobbs have created something original and infectiously fun – a promising first step in what could be a much bigger journey for both young writers.

- Andrew Broadbent

Comments