The Man Who Came to Dinner Spoiler-Free Review

The Man Who Came to Dinner - 4.5 out of 5 stars
The Adelaide Repertory Theatre
TICKETS: https://artstheatresa.sales.ticketsearch.com/sales/salesevent/159415

Every aspiring actor in Adelaide should make the journey to the Arts Theatre to see this show. If you do, you will receive an acting masterclass from some of Adelaide’s finest performers.

It is the late 1930’s and volatile radio personality Sheridan “Sheri” Whiteside has had a small accident that has left him temporarily in a wheelchair and stuck at the home of the Stanleys in a tiny little town in Ohio. Grumpy and irascible, but also charming when needed, Whiteside sets about causing mayhem both deliberately and inadvertently. His hapless secretary, Maggie Cutler, has the job of keeping Whiteside’s ego and schedule in check but things unravel when Cutler finds herself in love and wanting to leave while her boss is not so keen on this happening…

Under the deft and safe hands of legendary director Sue Wylie, this mammoth play (a tick over three hours) entertains and enthrals despite many longueurs in the script written by famed satirists George S Kaufman and Moss Hart. The cast is also a considerable size- around 22- and Wylie makes sure that nobody is wasted. The wonderful set by Gary Anderson works a charm despite issues with the doors on opening night. The costumes, hair, and makeup are all outstanding and a credit to the production crew and the company.

Leading the charge of talent as Sheridan Whiteside is Adelaide theatre raconteur, Peter Goers, essentially playing a classier version of himself and doing it extremely well. He bounces strongly off the rest of the cast and yet has an ability to know when he needs to be in the background more. Given that he is confined to a wheelchair for the bulk of this play makes this even more incredible.

Jessica Corrie, once again, proves why she is one of the best young performers on our stages today in the role of Maggie Cutler. Her performance is highly nuanced and there is not a second on stage when she isn’t engaged and connected to the story around her. Her comedic timing is pinpoint and her ability to break hearts is a joy to watch. Her scenes with Goers are some of the absolute highlights of this show.

Of the more veteran performers, it is an absolute joy to see Penni Hamilton-Smith and Brenton Whittle as the thorn in the sides to Whiteside. Hamilton-Smith’s Miss Preen chews up every bit of scenery whenever she’s on stage (when does she not??) and Whittle more than matches Goers for character has the hard done by Mr. Stanley.

Juliet Quick as Harriet Stanley has many memorable moments interacting with Goers and threatens to steal the show from everyone else. Rebecca Kemp brings the releases her inner fusspot as Mrs. Stanley (working beautifully alongside Whittle) while Rob Cusenza channels Harpo Marx (and Groucho and Chico as well) effectively in his turn as producer “Banjo”. Cusenza manages to turn a prop mishap into two minutes of absolute hilarity while poor Mr. Goers struggled desperately not to corpse onstage at his antics. Greg Janzow as Dr. Bradley, Christopher Ridings as John and Linda Lawson as Sarah also absolutely give their all every time they are onstage.

The younger cast are also fantastic, headlined by Matt Chapman as the journalist Bert Jefferson. His moments with both Goers and Corrie resonate strongly and give what could be a minor character some depth. June Stanley and Christopher Cordeaux have some excellent scenes as the Stanley children June and Richard. It is so heartwarming to see the future of theatre matching it easily with veterans showing an excellent ability to learn and be directed without being overwhelmed.

But amidst all these outstanding performances, two really set this production above most others. In his cameo as Beverly Carlton, cabaret legend Michael Griffiths brings class and his enormous talent to the little stage bringing some much-needed energy into a bloated second act. Of course, his cabaret skills are unleashed in a beautiful song that had the audience clapping enthusiastically.

Helen Geoffrys absolutely knows how to make an entrance, exit, and everything in between. Her incredible talent in the role of ageing floozy Lorraine Sheldon is worth the ticket price alone. Every line lands bang on target, every action well thought out for maximum effect and every punchline delivered with the ease and panache. An actress who should be doing this on professional stages around the world.

There were still issues on opening night. The first five minutes were unsettled which much garbled dialogue and an offstage Peter Goers barely audible. There were also issues with the houselights which made people think it was interval (why director Sue Wylie felt the need to drop the curtain to change over a few props is a complete mystery). Sound cues were also a mess at points (phone rings instead of doorbells). The audience was also very worn down before the third act and possibly could have benefitted from a second proper interval, however, given the already lengthy run time of this play, this was probably the more sensible option. It is also doubtless that much of the minor line fluffs and loose timings will tighten as the season goes on.

All that being said, this is one of the most outstanding productions of the year. The Rep, the cast and crew should be enormously proud of this effort. When the world is becoming increasingly horrible and sad, it is a play like this that remind us of laughter and the importance of theatre in helping us put these troubles away for a few hours. Assembling a cast with this magnitude of talent is no small feat and this play deserves full houses. You owe it to yourself to go and see this magnificent show while you can.

- Rodney Hrvatin

Comments