Pomona Spoiler Free Review

Photo credit: Sophie Livingston-Pearce & Alice Smith

Pomona - 4.5 out of 5 stars
Adelaide University Theatre Guild
TICKETS: https://www.trybooking.com/events/landing/1476481

Alistair McDowall's Pomona is not a play interested in giving you easy answers. Directed by Thomas Midena, AUTG's production leans into that discomfort, trusting its audience to sit with – rather than solve – the questions it raises. Is this a bleak vision of a near-future city consumed by corporate indifference? A group of friends spinning a Dungeons & Dragons campaign that's bled into something darker? A slice of Lovecraftian horror hiding in plain sight? The production never spoon-feeds you the answer, and it's better for it.

The near-future setting is grungy and lived-in, urban decay pressing in from every angle. Tahneisha Mottishaw's set makes inventive use of pallets and milk crates, repurposing the same rough materials into a bed one moment and an office desk the next – a nice echo of a city that repurposes people just as readily. Costuming (Atticus Chave) leans a little too clean for the grungy world McDowall's script demands – the wear-and-tear the set and lighting sell so well doesn't quite make it onto the cast. Where it does work is in the choice to dress several characters similarly, so the audience's uncertainty about who's who becomes part of the design rather than a distraction from it. Alice Smith's lighting does much of the heavy lifting in selling the film-noir-meets-dystopia atmosphere, and Jenna Matulick's sound design deserves credit – cues crossfade rather than cutting abruptly, so the soundscape never once yanks you out of the moment.

The script's non-chronological structure asks a lot of its cast, and this ensemble delivers. Every performer clearly knew exactly where and when they were in the story, even when the audience needed a beat to catch up – and when the pieces did click into place, you could hear it happen, with audible gasps rippling through the room at moments tying back to scenes from early in the play. The choice to keep off-stage cast visible, seated in the aisles or up on the Little Theatre's bridge, adds a layer of voyeurism that sharpens the play's horror and its commentary alike – you're never allowed to forget you're being watched, too.

Mia Livingston-Pearce anchors the production as Ollie, a wide-eyed, naive young woman searching for her missing sister – you believe her innocence completely, which makes what she gets swept up in land all the harder. Livingston-Pearce also takes on a second, murkier role later on (the play's slippery chronology makes it hard to say for certain how the two truly connect), portraying a woman doing whatever it takes to claw her way out of debt, sliding into increasingly extreme work along the way.

Jessie Chugg's Charlie is a security guard resigned to never amounting to much, played with a hard-won optimism that only comes from someone who's already been through the worst of it. Chugg may or may not also be playing a second character – a lonely Dungeon Master whose open invitation has drawn exactly one player in four weeks – and the ambiguity is one of the production's more haunting choices.

Louis Bianchini's Moe, Charlie's more switched-on counterpart, is a difficult needle to thread: a man with an innate blood lust he despises in himself, fighting to hold onto his humanity. Bianchini plays it with real nuance, never tipping into caricature – and the second-half fight choreography (Jethro Pidd) is a highlight, with one exchange between Bianchini and Chugg so convincing I genuinely thought a head had connected with a wall.

Photo credit: Sophie Livingston-Pearce & Alice Smith

Airlie-Jade Windle's Fay is matter-of-fact about her work – it's a job, done to get by and support her family, not to get rich – which is exactly why her decision to "get involved" and start pulling at the thread of Pomona feels so quietly terrifying.

Lily Watkins plays Keaton as coldly robotic, devoid of compassion, a character who seems to understand the dark truth of Pomona from her very first entrance – so much so that when a friend dies, her only concern is the unresolved cliffhanger in their D&D campaign.

Macey Lawson doesn't get much stage time as Zeppo but makes every second count, playing a larger-than-life zest for living as armour against ever truly caring about anyone. Zeppo's rule – don't get involved, even if you own half the city – gets a joyful showcase in a musical number (composed by Thomas Field) that the rest of the cast backs as enthusiastic karaoke dancers, a welcome absurdist release valve in an otherwise bleak evening.

Jessica Merrick rounds out the cast as Gale, a brothel madam who accepts her modest place in the system – until it's threatened, at which point she unravels into hysterics. Merrick is at her best in Gale's moments of power over those around her.

Midena's director's note insists this isn't a cynical play, but that's a harder sell than he might like: this is a script about loops, about lives that repeat themselves precisely because no one steps outside them, and it's only in "getting involved" that the horror underneath becomes visible. Glimmers of a hopeful reading surface in the closing scene, but the play's own circular structure makes that optimism difficult to fully justify. It's a disagreement with the play's philosophy though, not with the work on stage – Midena has handled his cast and material with real care, giving this ensemble the space to find their characters and come together as a genuinely cohesive, fearless troupe.

AUTG's production of Pomona finds every ounce of dread, absurdity and dark comedy this script has to offer, delivered by a cast working in complete lockstep with each other and with the material. Audiences will leave unsettled – not because the story spells anything out, but because it deliberately doesn't, and you'll be turning it over in your head long after the lights come up.

- Scott

Comments