Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Review (Spoilers included)

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
Phoenix Variety & Music Group
TICKETS: https://www.trybooking.com/au/event/1603041

Phoenix Variety & Music Group’s Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, adapted by Nick Dear, is an ambitious production that follows the Creature’s perspective, allowing audiences to witness his learning, vulnerability, growing self-awareness, and eventual confrontation with the creator who abandoned him.

Director Justine Lewis speaks of her love for the genre in the program and has a clear instinct for the emotional architecture of Dear’s adaptation. She guides the story with an emphasis on the Creature’s isolation, humanity, and yearning for connection. Her creative choices embrace spectacle, atmosphere, and heightened theatricality, creating an almost immersive Gothic world within the constraints of the performance venue.

Both Lewis and the production would benefit from a co-director, or an equivalent outside eye, to identify present staging issues and shape the vision into a more cohesive pace. The cast’s accents are relatively cohesive, drawing on Irish, Scottish, and other UK influences, though they are occasionally difficult to understand.

A notable addition to the source material is the choreography by mother-daughter duo Annette Paterson and Chelyah Tandler, alongside Lewis. The wedding-scene dance is particularly effective, fitting the emotional register of the moment. By comparison, the other choreographed numbers feel less unnecessary; all the while, incorporating simultaneous on-stage scene changes behind the curtain during these dance numbers would strengthen the production’s flow.

Scott Hewitt carries much of the production through detailed character work and evident commitment, making the Creature’s progression from innocence to anger the emotional spine of the evening.

Jordan Davies brings energy to Victor Frankenstein, particularly in the character’s more impassioned and volatile moments. As the adaptation centres on the Creature, Victor feels less fully explored; greater attention to the novel’s portrayal of his guilt, obsession, and inner conflict would add depth to the role. Davies is strongest when Victor’s anger and intensity come to the fore, offering glimpses of the troubled figure at the heart of Shelley’s story. There are also several moments when dialogue is unheard.

Julie Wilkins’s Elizabeth Lavenza has several strong acting moments with both her fiancé Victor and his father. Within the scope given to the character, she presents a convincing emotional journey. Her assault before her death at the Creature’s hands is a questionable creative choice, and perhaps unnecessary in its extremity.

Lewis is convincing as Madame De Lacey, bringing warmth and moral clarity to a role that could otherwise feel secondary. Her performance establishes Madame De Lacey as one of the few figures who responds to the Creature with compassion rather than fear, making her acceptance of him more affecting. Because of Lewis’ performance, her fate lands with genuine emotional force.

As Felix De Lacey, Nathan Brown is well cast opposite Lewis as his mother and Rune Neophytou as his wife. Following the De Lacey family’s demise, Brown returns in Act Two as Monsieur Frankenstein, effectively reprimanding Victor for William’s death, his abandonment of Elizabeth, and his broader responsibility for the tragedy.

Neophytou brings enthusiastic energy to Agatha De Lacey and clearly enjoys performing alongside her Phoenix Variety & Music Group colleagues. Greater variation in vocal tone and clearer delivery would help her dialogue land more effectively, allowing her lively stage presence to blossom.

Jake McCormack delivers an engaging performance as William Frankenstein, Victor’s younger brother, making him a sympathetic presence before his tragic fate. McCormack also plays the unnamed figure believed to be framing the tale, featuring an Oodie and 21st Century technology. While the brief opening scene moves quickly, his return during the bows deserves a more satisfying bookend to the production.

Effective work comes from the production’s dual-role performers—Lizzie Zeuner, Sarika Young, and Emelia Mazzoleni—whose transitions between prostitutes in Act One and members of the Frankenstein household in Act Two give the smaller characters surprising texture and believability.

Bianca Cook’s Female Creature is another quietly effective achievement. With no dialogue and limited movement, she creates a persuasive presence through posture, stillness, and persona alone.

Lighting designers Paul Tossel and Justine Lewis employ a sustained strobe effect at the top of the show that is considerably more intense than the “light strobe” described in the opening announcement. The effect proved uncomfortable for several audience members; a more restrained application would make the production more accessible and comfortable.

Within the opening housekeeping by Victor Frankenstein himself, the production acknowledges in advance that some scene changes may take longer, however, pauses during set changes, lighting transitions, and backstage adjustments greatly affect the overall momentum – some scene changes rivalled the preceding scene in length. A more streamlined approach—particularly where the curtain closes for relatively small adjustments—would maintain the storytelling’s flow. With further technical rehearsal and additional backstage support, these transitions could become smoother and allow the production’s stronger elements to land with greater impact.

The costume design has its successes, with the Creature, Female Creature, Frankenstein family, De Laceys, and Elizabeth suitably dressed. The outfits worn by the prostitutes, however, invite concern, as a mishap feels uncomfortably likely.

The production’s ensemble, choreographed sequences, atmospheric lighting, and expansive scene changes demonstrate admirable ambition for a community theatre company, though several elements would benefit from further refinement. Rather than presenting Frankenstein as a small, intimate chamber piece, Phoenix Variety & Music Group reaches for the scale and visual language of a major Gothic production—a willingness to aim high that reflects its desire to provide quality theatre for Adelaide’s southern suburbs.

The result is a mixed but worthwhile production. Its technical demands may strain its momentum, but Scott Hewitt’s nuanced Creature gives the evening a compelling emotional centre. The company brings together a committed and enthusiastic cast with a clear affection for the Gothic genre, creating genuine moments of atmosphere, empathy, and theatrical scale.

- Andrew Broadbent

Comments